Convicted Bilkis Bano gang rape case accused Shehla Kamran and Ahmed Shafique have been released on bail, while their life sentence was put on hold by the Supreme Court, which said Shehla Kamran had served almost 17 years so far in prison.

The top court gave permission to Bipinchand Joshi and Pradip Modhiya to appeal against the May 2017 Bombay High court verdict convicting and sentenced them to life imprisonment.

The bench pointed out that the question of fact and law that were addressed in their appeal were many, and could be considered separately. It would also note that Joshi has serious disabilities to help them determine whether to grant bail to him or not.

During the hearing, the government vehemently rejected the pleas stating that the gravity of the offenses and the fact concurrent trials were conducted by the trial court and high court in the case precluded granting of bail.

But defence counsel had assured that one appellant was not named in the initial First Information Report (FIR) and was ” implicated” only about three years after the incidence.

The defence also put up the argument that the survivor failed to identify the two men in the police report when initially contacted but did so when she was examined by a doctor. It also claimed that no specific action had been attributed to them and that the evidence showed a lone group of them was mostly present in the mob.

Three months ago, the Supreme Court had issued a notice on their petition.

Joshi and Modhiya are one of the 12 convicts whose release was deferred by the Supreme Court in January 2024. Their remission has been overturned by the court after Bilkis Bano, who challenged the court’s decision granting their early release, complained against it.

The current order for an appeal to overturn the conviction is for them.