Prohibiting the use of generative artificial intelligence (AI) would not be feasible and prudent, and will be disastrous because this is a direction that has to be followed, Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant said Saturday.
Speaking at the first-ever international conference of the Commonwealth Legal Education Association (CLEA) in the city, CJI noted that AI is changing the scenario of legal education, research and legal practice. But he warned that technology could not replace independent thinking, verification and accountability, he warned.
It wasn’t whether students were using AI tools, but whether their work with AI still showed an understanding, reasoning, and appreciation of the law, said Kant. He urged law school to reflect on how they assess their students and to educate them for the modern legal profession that is driving toward AI technologies.
The CJI pointed out that a blanket ban was impractical since it would drive the usage of AI into the “underground world”, whereas schools would be able to regulate and guide usage.
He cited the Supreme Court of Singapore, which allows the user of generative AI tools in court to use them but bear 100% responsibility for any resulting documents.
Kant also spoke about the accuracy of AI legal research. He cautioned that these may result in “plagiarized judicial references,” that they may be unable to capture the complete range of issues in judgments and that they may provide incomplete comparison of legal issues.
He emphasized that AI systems have no way to be considered authors, due to the lack of accountability for AI-generated content.
The CJI substituted that researchers should cross-check all legal mandates with their original sources; it should be made public how much they have used AI in creating reports, and researchers should be accountable for the information they publish. He argued that AI should be used to aid legal studies, not supplant legal decisions.




